Monday, January 29, 2007

Slavery, Sojourner Truth, and Us Today

In chapter 7, "Wrestling Match", Philip Yancey quotes Sojourner Truth. Her prayer was haunting, so I had to see if it was online. Here is a part of her prayer as she was trying to retrieve her son (who was sold to an out-of-state slaveowner).

'Oh, God, you know how much I am distressed, for I have told you again and again. Now, God, help me get my son. If you were in trouble, as I am, and I could help you, as you can me, think I would n't do it? Yes, God, you know I would do it.'

You can find the quote of her prayer in this chapter of her online biography: http://digital.library.upenn.edu/women/truth/1850/1850-19.html.
I read the entire biography, located at
The Narrative of Sojourner Truth website, trying to locate the quotation. It was so intriguing that I couldn’t stop. Then, when I read in Christianity Today about the movie "Amazing Grace" that’s coming out February 23rd, I decided to get more involved. Click on "The Amazing Change," here or in the linked article to find out about it. Slavery is evil and it is here today. Let’s see what we can do about it.

Prayer Study-Session Four (for 2/4/07)

[See "Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?" icon in the left panel.]

Study Guide for Chapters 6 & 7: “Why Pray” and “Wrestling Match”

In chapters 6 & 7 Philip Yancey raises some of the most common questions about prayer: What should I pray for? How many times? Will one person praying have as much effect as many praying together? Do I just need more faith? What about unanswered prayers? Does prayer really matter? What if I gripe at God?

Fortunately, here and in the rest of the book, he addresses those questions honestly. The study guide for this week helps probe chapters 6 & 7 and helps us formulate our own answers to these perennial questions.

A. A verse to memorize: Prayers by Jesus

Luke 22:31-32 (NIV)
"Simon, Simon, Satan has asked to sift you as wheat. But I have prayed for
you, Simon, that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned back, strengthen your brothers."

B. Book/Bible Study

Chapter 6: “Why Pray?”

  1. Yancey’s primary answer to the title question is, “Because Jesus prayed.” List at least three things you can learn about prayer from reading about Jesus’ prayer life.
  2. The last paragraph on page 79 lists “three rather large assumptions”. What are they, and how do they influence your attitude toward prayer?
  3. Your questions and comments:

Chapter 7: Wrestling Match”

  1. With which of the “God-wrestlers” mentioned in this chapter do you identify?
  2. “The opposite of love is ________________”, Yancey says. Do you agree with him on this? Why or why not?
  3. Your questions and comments

C. Class Discussion

  1. How does the “key principle” stated on page 82 fit with your concept of prayer?
  2. Your comments

Monday, January 22, 2007

Prayer Study-Session Three (for 1/28/07)

Study Guide for Chapters 4 & 5: “The God Who Is” & “Coming Together”

This is our third session studying “Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?”, by Philip Yancey. These two chapters explore two related questions: Who is God, and how can we connect with Him in a personal relationship? You can get a copy and study with us by clicking on the book’s icon in the left panel.

A. A verse to memorize: Prayer and the Holy Spirit—Romans 8:26 (NIV)

“In the same way, the Spirit helps us in our weakness. We do not know what we ought to pray for, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groans that words cannot express.”

B. Book/Bible Study

  1. While prayer is universal, concepts of God vary widely. How does one’s practice of prayer reveal his/her concept of God (including what Yancey calls “afterimages”)?
  2. What kind of being is the One we call “God”? How do we know?
  3. If God is everywhere, unlimited by time and space, how can we detect His presence?
  4. According to Yancey, why did Jesus pray?
  5. Compare other personal relationships you know of with Yancey’s description of how we can have a personal relationship with God.
  6. Explain “My feelings of God’s presence—or God’s absence—are not the presence or the absence.

C. Class Discussion

  1. Select one of the 6 questions above that you would like to hear someone else answer.
  2. Your questions and comments

Monday, January 15, 2007

Prayer Study-Session Two (1/21/07)

Study Guide for Chapter 3: “Just As We Are”

(If you are new to the study and do not have a book, you can order one by clicking on the icon in the left panel.)

With twenty-two chapters and only thirteen weeks in our study, we will look at two chapters most weeks. This week we will study only one chapter. It is packed with information and challenges. [Correction: last week’s verse to memorize was Mark 9:24, not Luke 9:24.]

A. A verse to memorize: John 15:5 "I am the vine; you are the branches. If a man remains in me and I in him, he will bear much fruit; apart from me you can do nothing.”

B. Book/Bible Study

  1. Yancey describes us “Just As We Are” with six terms. Only two of these are positive virtues. Is this a good way to describe us? Why not use more positive terms?

  2. Which of the six terms (the section headings) comes closest to describing your most common state of mind as you pray?

  3. If God knows us at our core and loves us anyway, why spend so much time on our sin and confession?

  4. Notice the quotation (page 35) from a character in an 1884 novel by Henry Adams: “Why must the church always appeal to my weakness and never to my strength!”
    1. Is the church any different now than it was seen in 1884 by that character?
    2. How do you respond to this complaint?
    3. What would be the result if the church always appealed to our strength and never to our weakness?
    4. What do you think of Yancey’s answer to this complaint?

C. Class Discussion

  1. This chapter suggests we come to God in prayer “just as we are”. Recall “Just As I Am” the “invitation hymn” sung at every Billy Graham Crusade. Compare the text of that hymn with the various selections for the “Hymn of Invitation” sung at worship services you’ve attended over the past weeks or months. What is the “invitation” presented in each hymn?

  2. Compare these four items in Chapter 3: (1) the F. Buechner footnote on page 32; (2) “Bearing Secrets” on pages 34-35; (3) the Rilke poem on pages 38-39; and (4) the footnote on page 43 on Milton’s “Paradise Lost”. What do they all have in common? Which speaks best to you?

  3. Your questions and comments.

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Prayer Study-Session One

This is the first week of our study of “Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?” by Phillip Yancey. If you still don’t have a copy of the book, you can order one by clicking on the icon on the left panel.

Last week we introduced this study and distributed the books that were ordered. This coming Sunday we will discuss the first two chapters. As noted previously, we will follow an ABC pattern to try to get at the heart of each chapter in our preparation for discussion.

Chapter 1: Our Deepest Longing

A. A verse to memorize (or meditate on): Luke 9:24

B. Book & Bible Study (Outline or summarize the chapter and ponder these questions)

  1. Did this chapter whet your appetite for the rest of the book or leave you less interested?

  2. What is your response to the last paragraph of the chapter (on page 17)?
    “
    If prayer stands as the place where God and human beings meet, then I must learn about prayer. Most of my struggles in the Christian life circle around the same two themes: why doesn’t God act the way we want God to, and why don’t I act the way God wants me to. Prayer is the precise point where those themes converge.”

  3. One of the best features of Yancey’s book is his honesty. He admits that his consistency in prayer and his level of satisfaction both fall short. How would you describe your own experience with prayer?

  4. Your Questions and Comments:


Chapter 2: View From Above
A. A verse to memorize: Psalm 46:10

B. Book & Bible Study: We saw in chapter one that “prayer stands as the place where God and human beings meet”. This chapter shows the different perspectives of the two parties who are meeting.

  1. Recall your own experience on a mountain (or a tall building). How did you feel looking up from below versus looking down from above?

  2. Picture rivulets of melting snow joining together to form a rushing stream . How can this help you see the flow of God’s love and grace?
    If you want water, how does the “view from above” help you find it?

  3. Meditate on Psalm 46:10. Describe in your own words the two parts of that sentence that are separated by the word “and”.

Your Questions and Comments:

Tuesday, January 09, 2007

Why Learn About Sharia?

Yesterday I posted “Islam—Definitions” with a link to an article about radical Islam. One of the terms to be defined is “sharia”. This link to Sharia In Action shows why it is imperative that we know what Sharia involves; and that we are prepared to stand against those whose goal is to impose Sharia in every country in the world. It’s hard to believe this from PowerLine:

“Nazanin Mahabad Fatehi is an Iranian teenager who was sentenced to be hanged for murder by an Iranian court. I had been unaware of her case until I read about it in the Power Line Forum last night. According to her account, Nazanin was with her sixteen-year-old niece and their two boyfriends when they were approached by three men who tried to rape them. The boyfriends fled, and Nazanin defended herself with a knife she carried in her purse. She stabbed one of the men, who later died. So far, at least, I haven't seen any version of the facts that differs materially from Nazanin's account.

Nazanin was prosecuted for murder and sentenced to hang. The verdict was apparently set aside by an ayatollah, and she is due to be retried tomorrow, January 10.”

Monday, January 08, 2007

Islam--Definitions

A wise professor of mine once said that definitions are the key to mastering any subject. If you can accurately define these terms, you have a very good handle on Islam and who it is that attacked the U.S. on 9/11 (and whom we will be fighting for years to come). If you can’t define more than 25% of these terms, you need to read this article

The War Against Global Jihadism, which is a brief introduction to Islam (and especially to the radical elements of Islam that have declared war against us). [Hat Tip to Hugh Hewitt] Hint: go to the article, and for each term you don’t know, hold down the control key and type F to bring up the “Find” window. Then find each term as it is mentioned in the article. If you still have trouble defining the term, go to http://www.wikipedia.com/ or check our some of the sources listed at the bottom of the article.

1

Islam

2

Muslim

3

Jihad

4

Jihadism

5

Jihadi, jihadist

6

Shia, Shiites

7

Sunni, Sunnites

8

Wahhabism

9

Twelvers

10

Imam

11

Ali

12

Koran, Qur’an

13

Caliph, Caliphate

14

Mahdi

15

Khomeini

16

Sharia, Shariah

17

Golden Age

18

Ottoman Empire

19

Andalusia

20

Sayyid Qutb

Saturday, January 06, 2007

Mere Mission and Simply Christian

Mere Mission

N.T. Wright talks about how to present the gospel in a postmodern world.

Interview by Tim Stafford posted 1/05/2007 04:00PM

N.T. Wright is a world-renowned New Testament scholar—author of Jesus and the Victory of God, The Resurrection of the Son of God—and bishop of Durham in the Church of England. He is also a keen observer of culture.

Christianity Today senior writer Tim Stafford caught up with Wright as he drove from meetings at Windsor Castle to his diocese in Durham. They talked about communicating the gospel in a post-Christian society.

Thursday, January 04, 2007

Prayer Study-Session One

The Koinonia Class at Calvary Baptist Church in Denver starts its study of “Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?” this Sunday, January 7, 2007. [If you haven’t already ordered a book, you can get one from Amazon.com by clicking on the book’s icon in the left panel.] Those of you who are not in the class, or cannot be present, can still participate by following the study guides I post here and by entering your comments online [by clicking on the word “comments” at the end of each post].

Each week we will follow this basic ABC outline: A verse to memorize (or meditate on if you don’t want to memorize it); Book study (taking either one or two chapters a week); and Class discussion). This week’s guide will serve as a pattern for what is to come.

A. A verse to memorize.

  1. Topic: Prayer and Faith. Luke 9:24 “Immediately the boy’s father exclaimed, ‘I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief.’” (Luke 9:24 NIV)
  2. To memorize it, break it into pieces and then add pieces one at a time until you can quote the entire verse verbatim. With the verse itself, memorize the topic and the verse reference (quoted before and after the verse to make the reference stick in your mind as well as the verse itself). I typically use the New International Version (NIV). Use whatever translation that you have and like. I recommend using only one translation so you don’t get confused.

B. Book Study.

  1. Take a moment to reflect on what you expect out of this study. Do you expect to learn something new, get some questions answered, change your prayer patterns, or . .?

  2. Scan the table of contents. Which of the five parts appeals to you most? Why?

  3. Before you start with the book, jot down any verse about prayer that you know. Don’t be concerned here about verbatim accuracy. Just write down what you remember.

  4. When you think about your own prayer life, what about it is satisfying? What would you like to change?


C. Class discussion. Bring your own insights and questions to class. Since we won’t have time for all the questions this study elicits, if you have a particularly burning question or insight, post a comment below.

Saturday, December 30, 2006

Good News for a "Post-Secular" Culture

I saw this headline that intrigued me in the online collection of news I get from a news and opinion aggregator called Real Clear Politics. The headline was “Holland's Post-Secular Future”. “Post-secular”, I thought—that must mean the article is about a growth of religious influence in Holland; and from other articles I’ve read about what’s going on in Europe, I guessed that the growing religious influence would be Islam.

There are millions of Muslim immigrants in Europe. And, since “demography is destiny” as some have said, I figured that the higher birth rate of Muslims would figure into the religious surge in Holland. I was pleasantly surprised to see that the article was about a resurgence of Christianity.

When I clicked on the headline’s link and actually saw the article, I was even more intrigued. The title is “Holland’s Post-Secular Future”, and the sub-title is “Christianity is dead. Long live Christianity.”

I encourage you to read the entire article. This clip is a clue to the sub-title:

"The idea that secularization is the irreversible wave of the future is still the conventional wisdom in intellectual circles here. They would be bemused, to say the least, at a Dutch relapse into religiosity. But as the authors of a recently published study called De Toekomst van God (The Future of God) point out, organized prayer in the workplace is just one among several pieces of evidence suggesting that Holland is on the threshold of a new era--one we might call the age of "post-secularization." In their book, Adjiedj Bakas, a professional trend-watcher, and Minne Buwalda, a journalist, argue that Holland is experiencing a fundamental shift in religious orientation: 'Throughout Western Europe, and also in Holland, liberal Protestantism is in its death throes. It will be replaced by a new orthodoxy.'"

The clue is in the last two sentences, and like a treasure hunt, it leads us to search for the next piece of the puzzle. What is the “new orthodoxy”? It is a return to the orthodoxy of traditional Christianity which has been rejected by the mainstream Protestant churches in Europe, but which has been embraced by “a growing group, most of them young people, who are genuinely interested, for whom this is all completely new." It’s strange to think that traditional, orthodox, Christianity is new to the youth of Europe. After all, it’s 2000 years old. But it’s new because the established churches seem to have replaced traditional views for something they thought would be more relevant. The result, though, is relegating the established churches to irrelevancy.

“There's statistical evidence to back up the "new orthodoxy" hypothesis. First of all, there's the undeniable fact of the continued decline and fall of the old liberal religious order. Worst hit are the mainstream Protestant churches, whose membership declined from 23 percent of the population in the late 1950s to 6 percent today. According to government estimates, by 2020 this figure will have dwindled to a mere 2 percent. The decline of liberal Protestantism has been matched by that of liberal Catholicism. The once-powerful Catholic Eighth of May group--a liberation theology movement born out of a mass meeting on May 8, 1985, to protest against Pope John Paul II's visit to the Netherlands--was disbanded in November 2003 because of lack of interest among its rapidly declining membership. More broadly, aging Catholic congregations mean that Roman Catholicism, too, will likely face another decade or so of declining membership. From 42 percent of the population in 1958 and 17 percent today, membership could fall to as low as 10 percent before leveling off around 2020.”

The real clue to the “post-secular” phrase is best seen in this quote: "It's evidence of a growing spiritual hunger in society. People are really searching for truth."

I saw some of this spiritual hunger myself this week. In talking with a couple of younger men about an upcoming study on prayer that my Sunday School class will start soon, the subject of guilt, repentance, and subsequent return to the same sin (behaviors, thoughts, and attitudes) came up. How can I expect God to forgive me and accept me when I keep doing the things I’ve just repented of?

I’m not sure how much it helped, but I was able to point out that all of us have the same problem, as even Saint Paul exclaimed in Romans 7:18-19: “I know that nothing good lives in me, that is, in my sinful nature. For I have the desire to do what is good, but I cannot carry it out. For what I do is not the good I want to do; no, the evil I do not want to do--this I keep on doing.”

The answer to Paul’s dilemma, and to ours, is grace. God did something for us that we could not do for ourselves. God gave us something we do not deserve. “You see, at just the right time, when we were still powerless, Christ died for the ungodly. Very rarely will anyone die for a righteous man, though for a good man someone might possibly dare to die. But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” (Romans 5:6-8 NIV)

This is the message that people want to hear. No one has to tell us that there is something wrong inside us. We know it all too well. What we want to hear is that there is a remedy, that there is hope that we can change (or rather that we can be changed).

With all the self-help tricks we can find we try to change ourselves. But in this inner core of our being we know it’s not a matter of just changing a habit, or going on a diet, or all the other resolutions we make, especially at this time of year. We want to change, but we cannot erase what we have done in the past, and we struggle to become the kind of person we want to be for the future.

As sincere as it is, the attempt by liberal Protestant Christianity (whether in Europe or here in the United States) to replace the fully God and fully human Jesus of traditional, orthodox, Christianity who “died for our sins” with the spiritual but only human Jesus who serves as a model for us to follow does just not have any appeal.

When a person is wrestling with the sinful nature that they know is at the core of their being, they don’t want a model. They want a Savior. Jesus is that Savior. That’s the “new orthodoxy” that is appealing to the young Christians in Holland. That’s the same message that has appealed to believers for 2000 years.

My church has the word “Calvary” in its name. We are now celebrating our 125th anniversary. What was it in the mind of the founders of that church 125 years ago that led them to use that word? Calvary is the place where Jesus was crucified. “Calvary” reminds us of the cross that towers above our church building. “Calvary” brings to mind the message bound up in the death-burial-resurrection event we anticipate at Christmas and celebrate at Easter—God, in the person of Jesus Christ, dying for us and becoming our Savior.

My prayer for my church and for others is that this time-tested message will never be replaced with the message that has proven to be ineffective in changing lives—the message that Jesus is only our teacher or model. We need a teacher. We need a model. But we need more: we need a Savior. Thank God, we have one in Jesus.

Thursday, December 21, 2006

Anticipation

I just finished reading Philip Yancey’s book, “Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?” for the first time. Wow!

As I’ve been reading the book, I’ve also started on some ideas for the study guide for the Koinonia class’s study that will start January 7. Our class will condense the book’s 22 chapters into a 13 week study, so it will be a quick trip through a book that will take multiple readings and a much longer time to digest.

One concept about prayer I gleaned from the book also applies to the study: realize that no one method of prayer works for everyone, or for anyone all the time. Do what works for you. In the same way, no one method of study works for everyone, or for anyone all the time. Since we’ll be looking at the book through different eyes, we’ll be trying different methods of study so each of us can find what works best in our own lives.

For those who are not in the Koinonia class, but who want to participate in the study along with us, I’ll be posting the study guide on this blog. You can participate by entering your own comments. I ordered enough copies of the book for all in the class. If others want a copy of the book, you can click on the photo of the book in the left panel and order one through Amazon.com at a discount. By the way, Koinonia members, the books have been shipped. They would have been here on the 22nd, but they have been held up in Salina, Kansas due to the closing of I-70 by the blizzard. They probably won’t be here until after Christmas, but I’ll get them to you as soon as they arrive.

I eagerly anticipate the first 13 weeks of 2007 because, having read the book, I know that everyone who participates in the study will see themselves, God, and prayer in a new light. As you anticipate the study, whether eagerly or with some skepticism, try this: take a moment to reflect on what you expect out of the study of “Prayer, Does It Make Any Difference?”. Do you expect to learn something new? Get some questions answered? Change your pattern of prayer? Develop a closer relationship with God? Or something else—something known only to you and to God.

The act of reflection, and of saying what you hope to receive from this study will itself be a prayer. See, it’s not so hard. You’ve started already.

Monday, December 18, 2006

Merry Christmas

I much prefer the phrase “Merry Christmas” to any substitute. I was in the grocery store and stopped by one of the tables where a sample of some product was offered. As I started to leave, the very cheerful lady who had offered me a sample said, “Happy Holidays”. My response was to ask, “And which holiday are we talking about?” Her answer was, “Anyone you want to celebrate.”

Well, the one I celebrate this time of year is Christmas. I appreciate someone recognizing my holiday and not being afraid to speak the word “Christmas”. With the vast majority of Americans relating to Christmas more than to other holidays, I’ll say Merry Christmas unless I know they are of a different faith. If I know the person I’m addressing is Jewish, I’ll make it a point to mention Hanukah. I would not think it polite to ignore a friend’s religion and just say “Happy Holidays”. Neither would I say “Happy Holidays” to someone in my family or a friend. So, to all of you, “Merry Christmas” and a Happy New Year.

New Study On Prayer

The Koinonia class at Calvary Baptist Church in Denver will start a new study January 8, 2007. To guide our study of what the Bible says about prayer, we will study the book "Prayer--Does It Make Any Difference", by Philip Yancey.

Along with the book, which you can purchase through Amazon.com via the link on the left panel, I'll prepare a study guide with some questions, activities, and suggestions for discussion. The class will consist mostly of discussion. For those not able to make it to the class, feel free to post your comments here.

If you haven't ordered your book already, contact me or simply click on the photo of the book on the left panel now.

Someone asked about an audiobook version of this book. Yes, you can also get an Audio CD for $19.49 or an Audio Download for $15.74. To get to either, click on the photo of the book on the left panel, and at the Amazon site see the box which says "Also available in: "

Blessings,

Rudy Antle

Thursday, December 07, 2006

Seeing Clearly Indeed

One of the surprises in my life as I get older is my openness to sources that I never would have considered in my young adulthood. I grew up before Vatican II and in a culture where most Catholics didn’t believe Baptists were true Christians, and most Baptists thought Catholics could not be saved. But a lot has changed in Catholic/Protestant relations and in my own spiritual growth.

I am pleased to point you to Catholic writings with which I fully agree. A great example is the following speech given by Denver Archbishop Charles Chaput at the Orange County Prayer Breakfast in Garden Grove California today (December 7, 2006). It is entitled “Seeing Clearly”.

You should read the entire speech: Seeing Clearly by Denver Archbishop Charles Chaput, and to entice you to do so, here is a sample.

“I began by talking about Christmas. Who owns it? Why are we supposed to be happy? What are we really celebrating?

Good will, joy, peace, harmony, the giving of gifts – these are beautiful and holy things deeply linked to Christmas. But not to Santa Claus. And especially not to a politically correct, secular Santa Claus. Joy is not generic. Good will needs a reason. We don’t suddenly become generous because the radio plays Jingle Bells.

Christmas is about the birth of Jesus Christ. We believe that Jesus is the messiah of Israel, the only Son of God, the Word of God made flesh. We believe that He was born in poverty in Bethlehem in order to grow and preach God’s kingdom, and suffer, die and rise from the dead – all for the sake of our redemption, because God loves us. Christmas is a feast of love, but it’s God’s love first that makes it possible. Christmas begins our deliverance from sin and death. That’s why St. Leo the Great called it the “birthday of joy.” What begins in the stable ends in our salvation. That’s why we celebrate Christmas, and it’s the best and only reason the human heart needs.”

(hat tip to Hugh Hewitt)

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

My "Red Kettle"

Please join me in supporting one of the most worthy of charitable organizations--The Salvation Army.

I have joined with The Salvation Army this Christmas to help their year-round work with people in need. They made it easy to have my own "Red Kettle" through my web site (without having to stand in the cold and ring a bell).

Instead of a bell, I'm using emails to call attention to the need and an easy and secure method of contributing. All you need to do is click on this link Salvation Army Red Kettle and follow the instructions on that page.

[Note the address starts with https://, indicating it is a secure link.]

Thank you for participating. May God bless you and your family this Christmas season.

Merry Christmas,

Rudy Antle

Friday, September 08, 2006

Jesus and Salvation Series (Part 19-B)

Welcome to the Summer 2006 study for the Koinonia Class of Calvary Baptist Church, Denver, Colorado. We’re looking at the issue of Jesus and Salvation, using the book “Is Jesus The Only Savior” [James R. Edwards, Is Jesus The Only Savior? (Grand Rapids/Cambridge: 2005)]. We encourage each person to buy a copy and follow along.


Christianity and Other Religions (continued)

Having learned that the claim that “all religions are the same” can only be made by someone who is either ill-informed or deliberately trying to down-play the differences, where do Christians go from here. How are we to think about other religions?

Here Edwards does something I’ve not seen anywhere else. He asks, “What does the Bible say about other religions?” This is a different question from what the Bible says about people who have never heard of Jesus or those who reject Jesus as Savior. The destiny of individuals is, of course, in the hands of God, and He hasn’t given us a clear message on what He will do. The question as Edwards asks it points us to a biblical model we can use as we speak about other religions, not their adherents.

Edwards summarizes almost eight pages with this paragraph (all eight of which you should read to fully understand the summary). Note that there are three different approaches the Bible takes, depending on the particulars of the situation.

“We may summarize our survey of the Bible’s attitudes toward other religions by saying that judgments vary from case to case. Cults that resulted in moral depravity and idolatry were wholly rejected as evil. Other cults were judged as falsifications of true worship, sometimes ridiculous and pernicious falsifications. Their adherents, nevertheless, were not condemned, and certainly not annihilated, but persuaded to abandon their folly and embrace the true God. Finally, some religions are seen as playing a foreshadowing role for the gospel of Jesus Christ. The primary example of a foreshadowing religion is Judaism…”.

Remember, this is not what anthropologists say, nor sociologists, nor teachers of world religions, and not even what pastors or seminary professors say. The Bible’s own approach to other religions is to either (1) reject some as totally evil, (2) judge some as ridiculous, and (3) see some as good, but incomplete—and then to see those as leading to the full revelation of God in the sending of His Son, Jesus. Edwards says, “Paul portrays salvation as a historical process leading from infancy to adulthood.” See Gal. 4:1-7 as an example.

Speaking specifically about the Jews, the idea of “two covenants”, one for the Jews and one for Christians, is rejected. God does seem to have a plan for the Jews, but we are not made fully aware of it. As with other non-Christians, we should share the Gospel with Jews, just as the early Christians did. “If Jesus is the good news of salvation for the world, no people, Jews included, should be excluded.” As Romans 1:16 says, “…it is the power of God for the salvation of everyone who believes: first for the Jew, then for the Gentile.” Such witness must, of course, be in the spirit of Christ and His love, but why should we refuse to share good news with anyone whom Jesus loves as much as He loves us.

Now we get to the question of whether people can be saved without having heard the Gospel.

Before getting to Edwards’ position, I’ll refer you to another book which presents a variety of approaches from diverse Christian points of view. Obviously, a secularist or humanist will either dismiss all religions or diminish their differences. And, someone from another religion may not even use the word “salvation” at all. This book, though, shows Four Views On Salvation In A Pluralistic World from four different, but Christian (Protestant), perspectives. I don’t have space to cover all that’s covered in a 270 page book, but here is a summary of the four views (taken from the back cover of the book):

Pluralism—all ethical religions lead to God
Inclusivism—salvation is universally available, but is established by and leads to Christ
Salvation in Christ—agnosticism regarding those who haven’t heard the gospel
Salvation in Christ alone—explicit faith in Jesus Christ is a necessary condition for salvation

In addition to these Protestant perspectives (and whatever variations or combinations of them are out there), we find in The Documents of Vatican II (1963-1965, Book II, Chapter 16) this Catholic approach, “Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience—those too may achieve eternal salvation.” You would have to read more commentary from Catholic scholars to know whether the meaning of “may” in that last phrase is “might, with conditions” or “have a possibility of”, or is “will be (or have been) given the desired privilege”.

In other words, to which of these familiar situations does “may achieve eternal salvation” relate: (1) Yes, you may go to the movies with your friends, once you have cleaned your room; or (2) Yes, you may go to the movies with your friends.

I included all of these to essentially say that there is no universally accepted answer to the question of what will happen with those who have never heard the Gospel. Edwards (and I) would fit most nearly in the “Salvation in Christ” approach above; yet we would both agree that we could be wrong.

The main point is not what my opinion (or yours, or anyone’s) is on this question. The point is that “The church has never been briefed on a Plan B of salvation.” (page 226)

My answer has to be, “I don’t know the answer to that question. I have to leave it to God. What I do know is that Jesus has given me (us) a mission to go to all people, share the good news of salvation with them, and “make disciples”. I can’t let a lack of an answer to a hypothetical question keep me from obeying a direct order from my Lord.

If we do our job of sharing the Gospel message, and let God do His job of convincing people of its truth and their need to accept it, then in the end we’ve done what our Lord told us to do. All the rest is up to Him. Anything more is needless speculation.

Monday, September 04, 2006

Jesus and Salvation Series (Part 19-A)


Welcome to the Summer 2006 study for the Koinonia Class of Calvary Baptist Church, Denver, Colorado. We’re looking at the issue of Jesus and Salvation, using the book “Is Jesus The Only Savior” [James R. Edwards, Is Jesus The Only Savior? (Grand Rapids/Cambridge: 2005)]. We encourage each person to buy a copy and follow along.

Christianity and Other Religions

We are now getting to the heart of the matter in our study of “Is Jesus The Only Savior?” Edwards states it clearly with a quote from Oprah Winfrey: “One of the biggest mistakes we make is to believe there is only one way. There are many diverse paths leading to God.” (page 203)

In addition to what we’ve already covered (the “dictatorship of relativism” and the danger of religious differences) there is another reason people make a statement like Oprah’s. We have an aversion to elitism. We don’t want religions to be unique. We are so sensitive to charges of nationalism, racism, sexism, and other forms of political incorrectness that we rush to harmonize all religions and downplay any differences.

There are similarities in various religions, of course. All religions have doctrines (teachings). All religions have rituals (worship practices) that express their beliefs about and relationship with the supernatural. All religions have ethical standards. If you look on the web for information about world religions, one site that comes up is an online adaptation of the book “Religion for Dummies ”. There you find,

“At its core, a religion is a belief in divine (superhuman or spiritual) being(s) and the practices (rituals) and moral code (ethics) that result from that belief. Beliefs give religion its mind, rituals give religion its shape, and ethics give religion its heart. Of the three elements that make something a religion (beliefs, rituals, and ethics), beliefs are the most important because they give rise to and shape the ethics and the rituals of a faith.”

When someone says, “All religions are the same”, they are probably thinking only about ethics. Ethics among religions are quite similar, often centering around some variation of The Golden Rule. Christians quote Jesus (in Luke 6:31) “Do to others as you would have them do to you” or His capsule summary of the Old Testament in the phrase “Love your neighbor as yourself”.

Yet when we look at the product of those religions—the societies that result when one of the religions is dominant—we have to admit there must be something else going on besides similar ethical teachings. Some ethical teachings are different. What is even more different are the ways the religions handle problems and violations of the ethical standards. What causes suffering? How do they deal with evil? Is there such a thing as “sin”. Is forgiveness possible? If so, how can one obtain forgiveness?

Now we get to the title of the book. Let’s ask the question another way: What religions claim to have a “Savior”?

Other religions have teachers and prophets.
Other religions have guides and models.
Other religions have law-givers and/or law-receivers
Other religions have way-showers.
Other religions have holy men and women.
Other religions have “spirit persons” (people in touch with “God”, the “Spirit”, the “Force”, or some other title.

Christianity proclaims a Savior.

(continued in part 19-B)

Sunday, August 27, 2006

Jesus and Salvation Series (Part 18-B)


Welcome to the Summer 2006 study for the Koinonia Class of Calvary Baptist Church, Denver, Colorado. We’re looking at the issue of Jesus and Salvation, using the book “Is Jesus The Only Savior” [James R. Edwards, Is Jesus The Only Savior? (Grand Rapids/Cambridge: 2005)]. We encourage each person to buy a copy and follow along.

Does an Exclusive Savior Threaten World Peace? (continued)

I discussed the first part of this chapter in the last post (Part 18-A). The major reason this question is asked inside the church as well as outside the church is that after 9/11 “we fear that the misuse of one religion or ideology will lead to violence, and that the violence of one jeopardizes the peace and unity of all.” Therefore, some feel, “If Jesus can be demoted from the sole savior of the world to one savior among others, that is one less match to ignite the powder keg.” (page 185)

The question, “Does an exclusive savior threaten world peace?”, is vital to ask and answer if we are to avoid the extremes of either a theocracy or a watered-down, lowest-common-denominator gospel of a Jesus who could never be a threat to anyone. And, let’s face it, the message of the Gospel can be divisive. Even Jesus said it could be divisive (see Luke 12:51 where Jesus predicted division over Him even within families). We’ve seen instances even today of someone being ostracized from his or her own family, or even killed in some societies, because they became a Christian.

Any religion that claims exclusivity perceives a threat when another exclusive religion is preached. Sometimes adherents react violently. In this regard, presenting Jesus as the Savior of the world does threaten world peace. So the way Jesus is presented is important.

Having shown the perceived danger which keeps many Christians from presenting Jesus as an exclusive savior, Edwards shows in the last half of chapter 10 how that danger is minimized by focusing on grace, Jesus as redeemer of all, and how the Gospel is God’s message of peace for all.

God’s grace is not the privilege of a few, but the gift God offers to all peoples. “The entire New Testament declares and repeats that in the particularity of Jesus, Israel reduced to one, that salvation has been accomplished for and is now offered to all creation.”

The term “offered” comes up again and again. Some Christians claim that grace and salvation are given to all with no response required. For them the question of free will is answered by saying that somehow in the end God will save everyone whether they accept Christ now or not. Edwards says the gift is offered to all, but that the gift must be received. God does not force it on anyone (and, of course, we should not use force in evangelistic efforts either). Thus the threat to peace is lessened.

Six pages are devoted to the New Testament concept of God offering salvation to everyone. Special care is taken in the New Testament to show that not only Jews could receive salvation through Jesus. “The Cornelius episode [in Acts 10 and 11] entered the bloodstream of the early church, and has never left it. It illuminated something that in the long history of Israel had lain in the shadows: the offer of salvation to all peoples.”

Walls were broken down for the Church to receive all who would come, not only from other nations, but “all people—“Jews and Greeks, slave and free, male and female—may be baptized by the Holy Spirit into the Body of Christ (Galatians 3:28; 1 Corinthians 12:12-18; Colossians 3:11).”

We should notice also that God’s redemption through Jesus is intended for all creation, including “the elemental spirits of the universe” (Colossians 2:20). That, of course, is a mystery we won’t solve, but it is important to know that Jesus is Lord of all.

In the section “Jesus the Peacemaker of God” Edwards re-emphasizes that there is no coercion behind the redemption of all. The focus is on Jesus breaking down the walls that divide so there is now nothing that artificially separates people. By breaking down the walls that divide, Jesus created the peace.

It’s important to know, however that:

  • the “peace” Jesus created is not what the world thinks peace is (the absence of conflict or a state of tolerance)
  • this peace is created by Jesus; it is not something humans make
  • this peace is not a personal mental state or attitude—it’s corporate rather than individual
  • peace refers to the reconciliation between God and His creation, and
  • it refers to the corporate peace Jesus creates within His Body

In one long sentence Edwards summarizes all of this: “The peace that attends the proclamation of the gospel is thus the announcement of a condition produced and delivered by God, not by human effort; it is a condition effected by the work of Jesus and declared in his name; and finally, it is communal rather than private or primarily emotional, affecting in material ways the relations of Christians with the world.” (page 200)

Since the point cannot be made too often, Edwards repeats the concept (on page 202): “The peace announced in the gospel is not achieved by an imposition of power on others but by the self-sacrifice of Jesus…The Gospel does not destabilize and threaten the world. It reconciles the world.”

In spite of this truth, we are often reluctant to talk about the gospel, the self-sacrifice of Jesus, and the salvation He offers to the world. Because we personally now encounter people from other religions, we would like to focus on the Great Commandment (to love God and each other) and forget about the Great Commission (to go and make disciples of all peoples). We don’t want to disturb the peace. If only all paths did lead to the same place, all would be well. So in the next post we will move on to the next chapter, “How should Christians think about other religions”.